Tigers 8, Pirates 5: McGonigle Homers, Detroit Holds On

August 17, 2026 - Pittsburgh - Kevin McGonigle hit one 405 feet to right-center in the second, Gleyber Torres scoring ahead of him, and the Detroit Tigers finally had the kind of lead you can waste and still keep.

They nearly wasted it. Framber Valdez (8-8) took an 8-1 lead into the sixth and left with it 8-5. Kenley Jansen threw the ninth, two strikeouts, 16th save. Detroit beat the Pittsburgh Pirates 8-5 at PNC Park and left town 61-64, in the same messy wild-card pile as everyone else who will not go away.

Fourteen hits. Seven walks. Thirteen men left on base. It was not pretty. It was two early innings and one homer, then a bullpen that had to finish what Valdez could not.

Two in the first, two more on McGonigle's swing

Zach McKinstry singled Torres home in the first, Colt Keith to third. Hao-Yu Lee singled Keith home. 2-0, and Carmen Mlodzinski (6-6) had already given up two before he recorded three outs.

The second was the homer. Torres on. McGonigle to right-center, 405 feet, 13th of the year. 4-0. Mlodzinski lasted three innings, eight hits, four earned. The Tigers had eight hits off him. That is not a quality-start problem. That is a lineup that hunted early.

Max Clark singled Lee home in the fifth. 5-0. Lee finished 3-for-4 with a walk, two RBI, and a throwing error that handed Pittsburgh its first run. Jake Mangum scored on that throw when Henry Davis bounced into a fielder's choice. 5-1. One mistake, one run, still a four-run game.

Eight to one, then Pittsburgh's four-run sixth

The Tigers' sixth looked like the knockout. McGonigle scored on Lee's walk. Brett Callahan singled Keith and McKinstry home. 8-1. Callahan finished with two RBI. Lee had the walk that plated the sixth run and the single that plated the second. Detroit went 4-for-16 with runners in scoring position and still scored eight. Walks and the homer did the rest.

Valdez had 5 2/3 innings, five hits, five runs, four earned, four walks, five strikeouts, 91 pitches. The sixth undid the line. Nick Gonzales, Flores Jr., and Jake Mangum all scored when Nick Yorke doubled to left. Davis singled Yorke home. 8-5. Valdez was done. Kyle Finnegan and Drew Sommers had to get the last eight outs with a three-run lead that had been seven ten minutes earlier.

Sommers threw 1 2/3 hitless, three strikeouts, ninth hold. Jansen needed eight pitches in the ninth. Two strikeouts. The Pirates managed six hits and went 2-for-11 with runners in scoring position after that sixth-inning burst. Eleven Detroit punchouts. No Pittsburgh homers. Just the one crooked inning. The Tigers walked seven, left 13 on base, and still won by three.

Line: Tigers 8 runs on 14 hits, 2 errors; Pirates 5 runs on 6 hits, 1 error; Valdez 5 2/3 IP, 4 ER.

A wild-card night that did not look like one

Detroit is 61-64. Pittsburgh is 61-66. Baltimore lost in St. Petersburg the same night and also sits 61-64. That is the AL wild-card picture in the middle of August: three clubs with the same number in the loss column, none of them inspiring, all of them still close enough that an 8-5 at PNC Park counts.

McGonigle's homer was the swing. Lee's three hits were the night. Torres reached twice and scored twice. Keith scored twice. McKinstry had the first RBI and scored in the sixth. The Tigers left 13 on base and still won by three. That is the version of this club that hangs around: loud enough early, sloppy enough late, just good enough at the end.

I would not call Valdez's 5 2/3 a statement. I would call Jansen's ninth the reason the statement did not get away. Sommers kept the sixth from becoming the whole game. McGonigle supplied the ball they will show on the flight home.

AthX Engine angle

Detroit finished with 14 AthX Engine team fantasy points, fourth on Monday's slate. Sommers scored about 12 pitching fantasy points in relief. Jansen scored 10. Lee had 8 hitting fantasy points. AthX Engine (our projection and scoring system) graded the 8-5 as a team night more than a one-name explosion, which matches a box score with 14 hits and one homer.

Explore the AthX marketplace for current player pages.

*Sources: ESPN box score, MLB.com gameday, AthX Engine daily scoring for August 17, 2026. AthX Engine fantasy scoring is for information only and is not financial advice.*